Hugh Banner Spitfire, $195
Summary: Here’s another potentially excellent tool that needs some work on the details. The Spitfire has a radical curve that offers great clearance. The pick penetrated well and bit securely in both Pont Rouge’s deep-freeze ice and Vail’s frothy slush, though its protective coating began wearing off with a little abuse. The plain-Jane grip and inadequate leash could be improved to bring this tool in line with the top performers.
Pros: Shaft gives excellent clearance. Solid pick penetration.
Cons: Lacks ergonomic grip. Minimalist leash.
Overall grade: B

Hugh Banner/Climb High: (802) 985-5055, www.climbhigh.com